The title of this album accurately describes what’s inside. Cat Jahnke explores many musical styles across the 13 songs of her second album, The Stories Are Taking Their Toll, but focuses on storytelling throughout. There’s a strong sense of character that gives depth to songs that might otherwise be cast aside as merely cute. That isn’t to say that this album needs to be redeemed, but that Jahnke’s deceptively pretty voice – imagine Reese Witherspoon singing without a southern accent – carries some true lyrical weight. The band sometimes falls into the trap of being too safe, but for the most part complements the songwriting superbly. The album’s strengths won’t be enough for everyone, but anyone in the market for a strong local blend of folk and pop with a dash of country flare will be quite pleased.

Published in Volume 65, Number 17 of The Uniter (January 27, 2011)