Discussion

Re: Visiting speaker accused of anti-Semitism

I think it’s important that people watch the movie that the controversial symbol is referring to. The documentary produced by members of Montreal 9/11 Truth is called “Montreal, The Next Terror Target?” and is available on youtube and Google video. Should you be interested in a dvd copy, please contact us by email mtl911truth@hotmail.com and we will see what can be done. But for now, the movie is available for free online and I invite you all to watch it.

– Patrick Biron in Quebec | March 26th 2009 at 6:43am | Link
The accusations against Professor Hall are ludicrous. Anyone who visits the website patriotsquestion911 will clearly see that there are hundreds of high ranking military, intelligence and government insiders etc. both in The United States and abroadwho have flatly rejected the patently absurd OFFICIAL 9/11 conspiracy theory, some even openly calling it a false flag operation.

Would those who’ve used Dr. Hall for target practice suggest that all of these people are “anti-Semite.” Amongst the many names listed include those who may well, indeed, be Jewish by faith. Would these same accusers suggest that firefighters, pilots, architects, engineers, and many others including victims of 9/11 families are all anti-Semite for questioning the gross anomalies of 9/11. Questions that we have have a moral obligation to pursue given the slew of history contorting agendas steamrolled into place courtesy of that horrific day.

The irony, is that meantime Bush old boy, whose family has
documented ties to the rise of Nazism via Wall St. bankers
is given the welcome mat and Hall’s accusers remain
clearly silent re. his visit.

– Natasha in Vancouver | March 26th 2009 at 12:56pm | Link
( Correction above: It should read ...” and family members of 9/11 victims.” .... I was in a rush and didn’t re-read the comment)

– natasha in Vancouver | March 26th 2009 at 1:00pm | Link
Try asking the people who accuse Prof. Hall of anti-Semitism what alarms they sounded when George Bush, grandson of Nazi financier Prescott Bush, rose to power, or when Karlheinz Schreiber revealed that he was doling out millions of dollars on behalf of Nazi financier/industry Thyssen to buy influence with Brian Mulroney and the McKay family. “Zionism” is an ideology that crosses national, ethnic and religious lines, while “Semite” is a cultural and linguistic label, which also crosses national, ethnic and religious lines. Anyone who equates the two is either ignorant or a liar. In fact, labelling people like Prof. Hall “anti-Semitic” is itself anti-semitic, because it falsely equates synthetic “Zionism” with “Jews.”

– David McIntosh in Toronto | March 26th 2009 at 1:21pm | Link
As a jew i take great offense to the slanderous actions of Rhonda Spivak, Evelyn Schaefer,the trash rag Jewish Post and the Jewish Defense League.
As well, Bob Freedman is an idiot if he is going to call Biron’s explanation “longwinded”.
The image Biron posted is not a “swastika”.
The image in question has a much different meaning and is quite easy to decipher unless your a fucking idiot which all of these clowns quite apparently are.
Professor Hall has been unfairly slandered and tarred by all of these people and i hope he brings serious legal action against them.
Let me repeat and emphasize.
These people have slimed Mr Hall and need their asses sued.
This whole issue is ridiculous and the U of W needs to step in and A) issue a big apology to Mr Hall that reaches a national level B) immediately ban Rhonda Spivak from their property C)continue to allow 911 truth lecturers on campus D) review their security apparatus so zionist thugs don’t ever pull this crap again.

I would say less than 5% of my friends and associates still believe the Torturing Bush Administration version of what happened on 911.

The official story is hogwash and impossible if you believe in physics and common sense.

People like Anthony Hall represent the very best of Canada and their brave opposition to the Fairy Tale or 911 is to be commended.
Not attacked by idiots.

People like Rhonda Spivak and the JDL’s Meir Weinstein do not represent any of the jews i know and honestly make us sick.

George Galloway should be allowed to speak in Canada and the zionist slander squad should find a new hobby.

Many intelligence agencies warned the U.S and Israel was one of them. FACT.

I suggest every jew watch “Fabled Enemies” which exposes the Israeli connection to 911.

911 was most definitely an inside job.

– Darren Androvsky in Winnipeg | March 27th 2009 at 3:12pm | Link
Professor Anthony Hall is a scholar of major stature. I have read his University of Winnipeg lecture and admire it. The attempt to smear Hall (and Patrick Biron) as anti-semites is despicable—but the slanderers are right about one thing at least: Anthony Hall is a vigorous and principled critic of the war crimes and war criminals they seem to vehemently to support.
As for the image at Biron’s website, it does indeed suggest a link between US and Israeli militarism and Nazism. Those who find this disturbing should read the January 15, 2009 address by Sir Gerald Kaufman, Britain’s most distinguished Jewish parliamentarian, to the UK House of Commons on the subject of the Israeli siege of Gaza. Kaufman denounces the language of an IDF spokesperson as “the reply of a Nazi”; he compares the Gaza Palestinians to “Jews fighting for their lives in the Warsaw Ghetto”; and he insists that his own grandmother, who was murdered in her sick-bed in Staszow by a Nazi soldier, “did not die to provide cover for Israeli soldiers murdering Palestinian grandmothers in Gaza.”
Hall’s slanderers of course have no shame, but let us hope the University of Winnipeg will have the integrity to express a due contempt for their behaviour.

– Professor Michael Keefer in University of Guelph, Ontario | March 27th 2009 at 3:26pm | Link
Correction of a typographical error. The last sentence of my first paragraph should conclude: “the slanderers are right about one thing at least: Anthony Hall is a vigorous and principled critic of the war crimes and war criminals they seem so vehemently to support.”

– Professor Michael Keefer in University of Guelph, Ontario | March 27th 2009 at 3:34pm | Link
Rhonda Spivak should stick to writing her hate on the walls of public toilets. That’s where she belongs.
Sitting in her own filth, drawing lewd cartoons.
This is a some of the most pathetic journalism ever produced.
Spivak’s gruesome smear deserves a courtroom encore.
The Jewish Post should be compensating Prof. Hall for damages.
The campaign of smearing 911 truth activists as anti-semites will not be tolerated nor be successful.
Rhonda, instead of character assassinations and hit pieces, why don’t you try writing about any of these interesting subjects ?
The USS Liberty, Odigo and 911,Urban Moving Systems and “The Dancing Israeli’s” and 911 ,the Lavon affair, Operation Susannah,Operation Northwoods,Gulf of Tonkin.

Thanks to the Uniter and Sandy for reporting fairly on Prof. Hall.

– DJ BALL in Vancouver,BC | March 27th 2009 at 5:49pm | Link
These slanderous comments about Professor Hall are grotesque! He is a man who has dedicated his life to promoting justice for humanity - in particular for the First Nations victims of genocide - whilst openly displaying his indignation for those who perpetrate crimes against humanity. Professor Hall is not anti-Semitic. As a student of his I know this. Clearly these Zionists no longer have a leg to stand on and so must reduce their arguments to squalid slander in the face of voluminous evidence of the Israeli government’s crimes against humanity. We all saw the clouds of white phosphorous gas emerging from the Gaza ghetto (despite Israeli imposed media censorship). It is because they have no leg to stand on that they ignobly throw around the term anti-Semitic thus besmirching those genuine victims of anti-Semitism throughout history. Professor Hall is performing his duty as one of the planets very few genuine academics in attempting to unmask the war crimes and terror attacks committed by states against innocent civilians. Professor Hall’s arguments are obviously irrefutable because if this was not the case there would be a long line of scholars refuting his assertions. These North American Zionists would never send their sons into battle, nor would they put on their tin hats and fight for the IDF. Their role is to merely ruin those who would seek to defend the International Law because it incriminates Israel more than any other country in the world. In many ways the fact that Professor Hall had a character assassination attempt launched against him by these armchair warriors shows that he is doing something right.

– Joshua Blakeney in Lethbridge | March 29th 2009 at 6:58pm | Link